56.  Table of Contents  Previous   Next

11/21/26

It’s Win or Go to Jail

What is it that draws some of us to music that’s on the edge? By “on the edge,” I mean the opposite of smooth. Let’s call it raw. I’m talking about music that’s full of emotion, that brings you to the edge of your chair, gives you goosebumps, and makes the hairs on the back of your neck stand up. You can find raw music in just about every genre. Its practitioners include Stuff Smith, Danny Gatton, Dizzy Gillespie, Gilles Apap, George Jones, and Art Tatum.

In the bluegrass world, there are Scotty Stoneman, Earl Taylor, Red Allen, Buzz Busby, the Lilly Brothers, Vern & Ray, Joe Val, and a few others who go so far out on the edge when they sing and play that sometimes you think they’re going to fall over. But they never do. That thrill adds another level of excitement to their music.

A friend of mine in Southwest Virginia says the raw type of music verses smother music is analogous to two political parties. Given that, I vote a straight Raw Party ticket every time.

Oh, but before I continue, let me say that the musicians on the smooth side are among the best in history and include some of my favorites. Their music just hits me in a different way. Some of my best friends play smooth music!

It’s rare to find another musician who has the same mind about music that I do. So when I find one and they find me, we want to play and pick and sing and play some more. Because to us, it’s the best music in the world. We can’t lay it down. We can’t let it go. We have to play it. We might have to call in sick, skip school, drive five hundred miles, hitchhike, tell our families we’re going to the office. Whatever it takes to make that music.

Raw musicians are few and far between these days in bluegrass. Maybe it’s because aging festival audiences don’t want to be shocked by musical pyrotechnics. If Buzz and Scotty were performing today, an ambulance might have to be on call in case of cardiac arrest! I say this as a senior citizen myself, so I hope my fellow oldsters aren’t offended.

There are a few exceptions to the trend to go smooth. Josh Gooding and JB Cardineau come to mind in the mandolin world. Multi-instrumentalist Brennen Ernst and fiddlers Billy Hurt and Nate Leath fit the bill too. Maybe you can think of some others and let me know.

**********

I met Bryan Deere at a jam around 1986, and within five minutes we were singing Buzz, Red, and a lot more. We sang the songs of Pete Pike, Chester Smith, George Jones, Vern & Ray, and the Lilly Brothers. And that was the first time we met. Once we found out we were musical brothers, we did some crazy stuff in the name of raw music.

Bryan called me on a Monday and told me about a singing contest that night at GW’s, a country music bar in Old Town Alexandria, Virginia. I didn’t really feel like going out on a weeknight, but it was a chance to lay some George Jones on the audience, and the prize was $250. Bryan had invited about fifteen friends to join us, and some of them were going to try their luck in the contest.

We didn’t find out until we got there that the house band, which was mediocre at best, would back up the singers. Whoever got the most applause would win. I thought, “What’s the likelihood that they’ll know any good music?” and said out loud, “I’m out. Y’all go ahead.” One of Bryan’s friends asked the band if they knew any George Jones, and they only knew “He Stopped Loving Her Today.” I couldn’t see myself trying to get through that song, recitation and all, with that band. So I repeated that I was not interested.

The singers went on one after another. The only one who was any good was Bryan’s friend Joan, who belted out “Crazy.” Meanwhile, our friends filtered out of the bar one by one. By the time the contest was coming to a close, Bryan and I were the only ones left at the big table. Then the check came. $230! Our friends had split, and we were stuck without enough cash to pay the tab. That was back when most people didn’t carry debit or credit cards around. I said to Bryan, “Let’s get in the contest. It’s either win or go to jail.”

We told the band we’d get our instruments from our cars and back ourselves up. They hesitated at first but eventually agreed. We got ’em and sang Buzz Busby’s “Cold and Windy Night.” We were right on, singing and playing. I wish it had been in a recording studio, because we’ll never get it that good again. We got the first standing ovation of the night, collected our prize, and paid the check.

**********

Another time, Bryan told me that our bass-playing friend Joe wanted us to play for tips at a bar in Accokeek, Maryland. “All right, I’ll do it,” I said. I didn’t want to miss a chance to belt out some Red Allen songs.

It turned out to be one of the roughest bars I’ve seen, and I’ve seen a lot of ’em. It seemed like everybody who came in the place was already totally drunk. They’d probably been kicked out of another bar and come to the drunk’s last refuge. Usually, bar patrons won’t bother the musicians because they want the music to keep going. But this time things were different. About ten minutes after we started, a dude in a leather jacket and bandana asked for “Ghost Riders in the Sky.” I didn’t want to do that song. I wanted to do “Close By” or something like that, but I figured I’d better do his song to avoid trouble. I forgot some of the words, tried to make them up, and started laughing. Mr. Bandana thought I was laughing at him and wanted to start something.

We knew from experience to get our instruments into their cases at the first sign of trouble, so we packed them up. It seemed like some of the other patrons were about to join their buddy in pounding us, so I said to Bryan, “I saw this in a Gene Autry movie.” I picked up a chair with my left hand and used it to fend off the drunks while holding my mandolin case in my right. Bryan followed suit. Joe left his bass and skedaddled. We backed out the door wielding the chairs, ran for our cars, and took off. Joe picked up his bass, which was unscathed, the next day.

I’ve recently met a crop of younger musicians who share my love for the raw brand of bluegrass music. Brennen, Nick, Steve, Rob, and a few others have already joined me on a few escapades because we have to play that music. We just have to.

Photos:
1. Stuff Smith, Buzz Busby, Red Allen, Dizzy Gillespie
2. Gilles Apap, Danny Gatton, Joe Val, George Jones
3. Bryan & Me, about 1990
4. The kind of place we played.

Tom Mindte
November 2026

Table of Contents   Previous   Next


Stuff Smith, Buzz Busby, Red Allen, Dizzy Gillespie


Gilles Apap, Danny Gatton, Joe Val, George Jones


Bryan & Me, about 1990


The kind of place we played.