47.  Table of Contents  Previous   Next

10/30/26

The Case of the Mysterious Dobro Player

I think the pros who play music on the road for a living have it pretty rough. Roni Stoneman told me the Stonemans usually didn’t even know what state they were in. The bus would stop, they’d get off, change, play, get back on, and head to the next town. And being on the fringe of that world, I can tell you that most performers have to play the same songs night after night—the same set, the same jokes, the same, the same. So, what do they do to alleviate the boredom? A lot of them play practical jokes on one another. Maybe I’ll catalog some of those pranks someday, but this morning, I just want to tell you about one that was played on me by a seasoned traveler and performer, Patsy Stoneman. As soon as I get through with that, I’ll get to the mysterious dobro player, so stick around awhile.

Ernest V. and Hattie Stoneman, better known as Mom and Pop, were being inducted into the Gennett Walk of Fame in Richmond, Indiana, in 2009. Gennett was a record label that recorded and manufactured records during the 1920s and ’30s. The Walk takes you past large ceramic and bronze medallions resembling 78-rpm records, each featuring an image of an honored artist who recorded for the label.

The Starr-Gennett Foundation held a special celebration to honor that year's inductees. As descendants of Mom and Pop Stoneman, Patsy, Donna, and Roni Stoneman were invited to perform. Patsy asked me to play guitar and sing harmony with her and her sisters.

That was a big deal for me as a record collector who owns a few prized, rare Gennett records. But an even bigger thrill was having the opportunity to perform with the last surviving children of Pop and Hattie.

The night before the show, when we rehearsed at the hotel, Patsy asked me if I wanted any guitar solos. I gave her an emphatic “No.” I told her, “I can play rhythm guitar and sing, but I don’t take solos.” For some reason, that brought a smile to Patsy’s face.

The next day, we were the last act on the program. Before us came a jazz band that emulated the bands of the twenties, several folk singers, and Bradley Kincaid’s son, who sounded just like his old man. Meeting him was a treat. Roni gave us a little pep talk, telling us to be sure to smile and act like we were having a good time. I thought, ‘You’ve gotta be kidding. I’m having the time of my life!’ Patsy scowled—she didn’t want to be told what to do, even if it was to have a good time.

We took our places, and the first song began. After the first chorus, Patsy looked at me and said into the microphone, “Take one, Tom.” Boy, did I try! I probably should have just kept playing rhythm, but I went for it. My break sounded a little worse than Wichita of Roadhog Moran and the Cadillac Cowboys. (If you know, you know). The audience caught on to what was happening and laughed, then gave me a big round of applause, which made it worse.

After the show, I asked Patsy why she had embarrassed me like that. She laughed and said, “We always do that to the new guy. Now you’re an honorary Stoneman.” Wow! An honorary Stoneman. How about that! I got to play with the ladies several more times over the next few years.

When Patsy passed away and Donna retired, Roni asked me to play mandolin with her on a few shows. She took me to places I never dreamed I’d play, including the famous Farm & Fun Time in Bristol and the Midnight Jamboree at the Texas Troubadour Theatre in Nashville, where the mysterious dobro player appeared one night.

Roni, Jeremy and Corrina Stephens, Mike Bub, and I were in the green room, waiting to go on. A man walked in with a guitar case and sat down. He didn’t say anything; he just smiled at some of our jokes and nodded occasionally.

After a few minutes, Roni motioned for me to go into the dressing room, where she asked, “Who is that guy? Do you know him?”

Me: “No, I thought you hired him.”

Roni: “Well, I’m gonna find out.”

Roni walked back into the green room and said, “Excuse me, sir, who are you?”

Mystery Man: “I’m your dobro player.”

Roni: “We don’t have a dobro player. Are you here on the wrong night?”

Mystery Man: “No, I’m here to play with you, Roni Stoneman.”

I expected her to ask him to leave, but instead, she said, “Oh yeah? Let’s hear you play it.” He uncased his axe and played a few licks, and he wasn't half bad.

It was time to go on, so Roni said, “C’mon,” and he joined us onstage. Roni gave him a solo on nearly every song, and he played decently.  He had some of Josh Graves’s chops and could play a little bit of the newer styles too.

After the show, he put his instrument back in the case and left. None of us ever knew his name or where he came from.

Photos:
1. At the Midnight Jamboree with the Mysterious Dobro Player. Do any of you know his identity?
2. Me with Roni, Patsy, and Donna Stoneman – Richmond, Indiana, 2009
3. Mom and Pop’s medallion on the Gennett Walk of Fame. (Champion was a sister-label to Gennett)

Tom Mindte
October 2026

Table of Contents  Previous   Next



At the Midnight Jamboree with the Mysterious Dobro Player.
Do any of you know his identity?


2. Me with Roni, Patsy, and Donna Stoneman
Richmond, Indiana, 2009


Mom and Pop’s medallion on the Gennett Walk of Fame.
(Champion was a sister-label to Gennett)